From Nothing Burger to Everything Bagel: How Love Island’s Jen and Gal Won the Post-Villa PR Game

By: Megan Graham

In the months following a season of "Love Island”, there’s the typical slew of breakups, brand deals and anticipation for the post-villa reunion that follows. The unique nature of the show being filmed nearly every day means America is always watching and critiquing Islanders’ every move. The outcome of the leaderboard is not the only factor in who finds themselves with newfound stardom after the show.

Image Source: Pop Crave on X

For this past season’s Jen Terry and Gal Tshnieder, public perception shaped their journey from day one. Neither was particularly well-received during the season, with Jen being coined a “nothing burger” and Gal being disliked for the way he went about his time on the show. The two had a short (and not quite sweet) relationship that ultimately resulted in them both leaving the villa. Flash forward to now, and they are two of the most prominent cast members that came out of this season, and have arguably become some of the most iconic.

So, what does this have to do with PR?

Jen and Gal may have had two of the most surprising post-villa reputation shifts to date. This isn’t because fans just randomly changed their minds, but because both Jen and Gal intentionally leaned into behaviors that PR professionals know help rebuild trust and credibility with an audience. They leaned into their public commentary and took control of the narrative in a way that benefitted their individual brands. Public relations is about building and maintaining image and relationships, and they did just that.

Jen: From “Nothing Burger” to “Everything Bagel”

Jen’s PR obstacle was being seen as boring early on. A lack of screentime led viewers to think she lacked personality, and many wrote her off. Towards the end of her time in the villa, viewers started to see more of her, and after she exited, her interviews and social content showcased more of her humor and authenticity. Her “realness” changed people’s perspectives, and made them appreciate that she wasn’t putting on a fake or dramatized persona just to be a leading character on the show. Fans realized that she wasn’t boring, they just hadn’t seen enough of her. Sometimes PR isn’t changing how you act, it is simply revealing more of yourself. Humans crave connection, and connection often stems from relatability. This is hard to find on a dramatized show, but staying consistent to herself paid off in the end.

Image source: Tiktok

Gal: Don’t Fight the Narrative, Just Redirect It

Gal left the Villa with one of the worst reputations after how he ended things with Jen. His short arc on the show left viewers with little time to connect with him, and contributed to his negative perception. Gal received a lot of backlash after coming home, but instead of becoming defensive, he leaned into the memes. He joked about his infamous line “big night for Gal”, acknowledged his family making fun of him and even posted videos making fun of himself for things he did on the show. This self-aware route won him back a lot of points, and even boosted his engagement and image online. Self-awareness is a PR pro-move, because audiences love to see people and brands take responsibility, and admit their faults. No one’s perfect, so taking responsibility and acknowledging the situation early is often the best thing you can do after a PR faux pas.

Collaboration: Why Everyone Wins

Collaboration: Why Everyone Wins

To take things even further, the thing that truly set Jen and Gal apart was their unique collaboration. They met up post-villa and organized a photoshoot that played on their tensions in the villa, which they posted on Instagram with the caption:

 “Here’s a com-promise. Jen gets free coffee for life. Y’all forgive me”

Image Source: Instagram

The photoshoot playfully addresses Gal’s treatment of Jen, and her “getting him back”. Their collaboration and the concept they chose for it communicates that there is no bad blood between the two, and that they have moved on. 

Furthermore, it provides professional benefits to both of them. Jen, who works as a model, gets viral modeling content that promotes her career, and Gal gets exposure for his surf and coffee shop, Saba Surf, through someone viewers are rooting for. This well thought out campaign makes the collaboration feel authentic rather than transactional, and comes full circle in their relationship, which gives fans a sense of closure.

The Outcome: Building Brands and Beyond

This photoshoot took off, and solidified their PR standing. Fans loved it, and Jen and Gal continued to play into it. They enacted their characters as hero and villain, capitalizing on their moment in the spotlight. Jen launched strategic partnerships with both Carl's Jr. and Popup Bagels, highlighting her metaphorical transition from nothing burger to everything bagel. Gal’s shop hosted a “free coffee for anyone named Jen” promotion, and posted about their team’s support for her on socials, which continued to drive engagement and sales for them.

Image Source: Popup Bagels on Instagram, SabaSurf on TikTok

The “Love Island” universe is extremely culturally relevant, and with PR, capitalizing on culture is no different. Capturing and holding viewers’ attention is so important, and taking advantage of pop culture or timely relevance can make or break a campaign. Jen and Gal did this right every step of the way, and managed to rewrite the negative perception of the hand they were dealt. 

Ultimately, Jen and Gal’s post-villa strategy is a masterclass in modern branding and PR. When bad editing or early backlash hits, they highlight the importance of not fighting the narrative, but taking ownership of it. By leaning into fan culture, self-awareness and humor, and turning villa friction into smart, mutually beneficial collaboration, they flipped the script. Beyond the viral photoshoots and meme-driven partnerships, their success highlights a core PR truth: authenticity builds longevity, proving that aligning your brand with audience perceptions is how you turn a “nothing burger” situation into an “everything bagel” win.

Previous
Previous

Dating, Then vs. Now: Why Nobody Knows What We Are Anymore

Next
Next

The Public Relations Skills You’re Subconsciously Learning at Your Part-Time Job